Our “Barnyard” analysis from a year ago resulted in 6 out of 8 points indicating that the market would be favorable over the next 6-18 months. That has come true, with the S&P 500 up nearly 20% since then. We expect many will be surprised by the latest Barnyard Forecast which we present below.
The above introductory comments are edited excerpts from an article* by Greg Donaldson (risingdividendinvesting.blogspot.co.il) entitled Barnyard Forecast: More Bull to Come or Is the Bear Growling?.
Donaldson goes on to say in further edited excerpts:
…We [recently] updated our “Barnyard Forecast” model – a basic model we use to determine whether the current environment is accommodative, neutral or restrictive towards stock market growth – gets its name from the acronym of its components: economy, inflation, earnings, and interest rates = opportunity for stock market appreciation (E+I+E+I=O).
Since 1990, the Barnyard model has correctly predicted the general direction of the market over the next 6 to 18 months with approximately 80% accuracy.
Each of the above mentioned 4 factors is rated as positive (2 points), neutral (1 point), or negative (0 points) for stocks based upon historical relationships between that component’s economic data and its likely effect on the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy and market reactions. The total points are then added up to arrive at a score between 0 and 8. A score above 4 indicates a positive environment for stocks.
Economy – 2 Points
When the economy is growing slowly, the Federal Reserve’s projected actions over the next 12 months should favor stocks. The Forecast score is positive when economic growth is less than the optimal, non-inflationary rate of economic growth of 3%.
- Markets & Economy NOT Topping Out & Ready to Roll Over – Here’s Why
- Are We In A Pre-crisis Period? A Look At 8 Possible Triggers
- Don’t Fear End of QE or Beginning of Higher Interest Rates – Here’s Why
- Borrowing Binge & Asset Bubble to Continue Until…Until
- History Says “Expect An Economic Crash AGAIN In 2015″ – Here’s Why
Economic growth has improved significantly since the 1Q 2014 numbers. However, year-over-year GDP growth remains below the 3.0% mark. At this moment, we’re at about 2.5% with the 3-5 year range between 1.5% and 3.0%. Economic growth would need to be at least 3.0% before the Federal Reserve would start taking any action to raise rates. In our view, even 3.0% might be too low in light of the other data coming from the economy. The bottom line: the economy is still not growing fast enough to warrant monetary policy tightening. Positive for stocks – 2 points.
Interest Rates – 2 points
Historically, the yield curve spread (difference between long-term and short-term interest rates) has been a predictor of economic performance. As long as the spread remains positive, stock markets tend to rise. When it turns negative, that is a danger signal for stocks.
Spreads between long-term and short-term rates are currently very positive. The 2-year U.S. Treasury is yielding around 0.5% versus nearly approximately 2.5% on the U.S. Treasury, a positive spread of 2.0%. Since we are nowhere near a negative yield curve, this component of the model strongly suggests a favorable environment for stocks. 2 points.
- Myth #1: There Is A Direct Relationship Between Interest Rates & Stock Prices
- Interest Rates Play A MAJOR Role In the Behavior Of the Stock Market – Here’s Why
- Interest Rates to Remain Low As Far As the Eye Can See? Perhaps, BUT
Earnings – 2 points
Earnings growth is a statistically significant driver of stock market prices. Over the long-term, earnings growth for U.S. corporations has been 7%. The Forecast scores growth greater than 7% as being positive for stocks.
In September 2013, the Qtr.2 earnings were only 3% – well under the 7% level. This time around, earnings growth is markedly improved. Last quarter’s earnings growth was close to 9%. Earnings growth projections are for even better grow over the next 12 months. Companies have continued to grow despite the lackluster economy. Positive for stocks – 2 points.
Inflation – 2 points
The Federal Reserve’s optimal level for core inflation is approximately 2% to 2.5% year-over-year. Core inflation under 2% allows the Fed to stimulate the economy without creating inflationary problems and is positive for stocks. Inflation greater than 2% is negative for stocks.
Mr. and Mrs. America tend to watch the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and core CPI (excludes energy and food). However, the Federal Reserve pays more attention to the Personal Consumption Deflator, which tends to run about 0.5% less than CPI. At the moment, CPI is about 2.0% and the Personal Consumption Deflator is around 1.5%. Unless inflation ticks up at least another 0.5%, we don’t anticipate the Fed is going to raise rates. Positive for stocks – 2 points.
- Inflation Will Become a Huge & Growing Problem Beginning In 2015 – Here’s Why
- High Inflation IS Coming – It’s Just A Question Of When – Here’s Why
= Opportunity for Stocks – 8 out of 8 (Positive)
Adding each of the 4 factors totals a perfect score of 8, which indicates conditions are very favorable for stocks.
…While there are many unknowns surrounding the Federal Reserve’s next moves, our Investment Policy Committee agrees with the Forecast’s projection of continued positive returns for the market over the next 6 to 18 months.
Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions in the above article are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original post. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.
If you liked this article then “Follow the munKNEE” & get each new post via
Sure, the market is getting more and more expensive, debt levels are still high around the globe, and the Drudge Report assures us daily that the world is going to hell in a handbasket, but does this signal the end is near for stocks and the economy? This article presents 4 “big picture” charts or indicators to help determine whether the markets and economy are topping out and ready to roll over. Let’s take a look. Read More »
Trying to predict markets more than a couple of days into the future is nothing more than a “wild ass guess” at best but, that being said, we can make some reasonable assumptions about potential outcomes based on our extensive analysis of these 6 specific price trend and momentum indicators. Read More »
Brace yourself! The stock market is ripe for a nasty selloff according to a number of politicians and even more market pundits – but not so fast. Two very reliable long-term recession indicators strongly suggest that a correction – or worse, the end of the bull market – is highly unlikely given the current state of the economy. Let me explain. Read More »Read More »
There are a number of potential pitfalls out there for the market but, right now, the behavior of the main catalysts for a major correction suggest that there continues to be more right than wrong with the market. Let me explain. Read More »
Some investors are sure we’re heading for a crash because we’ve had such an uninterrupted rise in stocks but these things can last much longer than most people realize. While a crash is never out of the realm of possibilities, just because stocks are up doesn’t mean they have to immediately crash. Eventually they will be right. It’s the timing that gets you on these type of calls. Read More »
Everyone knows that interest rates are going to rise in the future so the real question is not whether they will rise, but when and by how much. [This article analyzes when that will most likely be.] Read More »
Events and conditions do not make investors behave in any particular way that can be identified as shown in this analysis of the supposed relationship between interest rates and stock prices. So much for the popular claim that “Interest rates drive stock prices”! Read More »
To understand how the stock market behaves it is imperative to realize that the stock market is overwhelmingly influenced by interest rates. It’s difficult to overstate this key fact. Interest rates are the bone and marrow of the stock market. More specifically, the stock market is ruled by long-term and short-term interest rates creating an overriding framework for what drives the market in which different sectors do better or worse at different points in the economic cycle. This article explains the behavior more fully. Read More »
A temporary period of deflation will result from the end of the Fed’s massive asset purchases followed by a period of inflation that will make the ’70s seem like an era of hard money. Here’s why. Read More »
There have been many econoblog posts of the form, “ha, ha, the people predicting inflation have been wrong so far, when will they give up?”. Let me try to explain why we know high inflation is coming eventually. Read More »
The frequency of financial crises and recessions is quite high: on average, there is one crisis every 58 months (using data from the US National Bureau of Economic Research). In other words, statistically speaking, we should expect the beginning of the next crisis in April 2015, which would end by March 2016. There are 8 possible scenarios that could cause the next crisis. Let’s take a look at each. Read More »
History strongly suggests that, rather than a return to a nice, placid world of “normal” interest rates, we are likely to see a continuation of the borrowing binge/asset bubble until real rates spike as a result of either soaring nominal rates soar or plummeting inflation. Here’s why that is the case. Read More »
The Fed and the bond market are responding appropriately to declining risk aversion and a somewhat improved economic outlook. There is no reason to fear the end of QE or the beginning of higher short-term interest rates. Let me explain further. Read More »
Large numbers of people believe that an economic crash is coming next year based on a 7-year cycle of economic crashes that goes all the way back to the Great Depression. Such a premise is very controversial – some of you will love it, and some of you will think that it is utter rubbish – so I just present the bare bone facts below for you decide for yourself if it is something to seriously consider protecting yourself from in 2015. Read More »