With markets so calm, it’s easy to become complacent about the corrosive effects that volatility can have on long-term investment success. If you don’t need the money for a long time, you can ride out the inevitable market squalls but if you’re close to or already drawing from those funds, volatility can be costly…Let me explain further.
The above introductory comments are edited excerpts from an article* by Chris Marx & Kent Hargis (blog.alliancebernstein.com) entitled Volatility in Retirement—What a Drag!.
Their article goes on to say in further edited excerpts:
We are all prone to performance chasing, leading many of us to make the classic mistake of buying high when markets boom and bailing out too quickly when they bust – and forfeiting the chance to participate in subsequent recoveries. It’s harder to resist these impulses during volatile periods, which can erupt with little notice. Even if you have the stomach to ride these upheavals without changing your allocation, volatility can still hurt.
It’s a function of the cruel math that governs the difference between average returns and compounded returns: if a stock falls by 50%, it needs to rebound by 100% to restore lost ground. The steeper the fall, the harder it is to climb back. Compounded over time, big price swings can be a significant drag on long-term performance.
We see this “risk drag” at work in the middle line chart of the display below, which compares the performance of an initial $100 investment under three different patterns of returns, all of which average 8% per year over a five-year span. While the end result for both of the more volatile paths is the same, the consistent return path’s final destination is better.
The stakes are much higher for investors in the post-accumulation stages—whether they are retirees living off their savings or plan sponsors paying claims from their pension funds. Risk drag reduces both the expected value of those funds and the chances that there will be enough money to meet future needs.
In the most basic sense, the problem arises because of the differences between the steady timing of withdrawals and the unpredictable swings in the fund’s investment value. High volatility increases the chances that you’ll be taking money out when the portfolio is suffering, thereby locking in losses.
The impact can be particularly pernicious if the downdraft occurs early in the withdrawal period. As the right-hand line chart of the display above shows, when taking out $5 a year, the $100 investment fares much worse under Path A, which suffers a 20% drop in the first year, than under Path B, which sees the 20% drop in the last year – and both do worse than the steadier Path C. Clearly, the path matters—and the smoother the ride, the better.
Taming volatility can also help ease this investor’s biggest fear: running out of money. To calculate the probability of such an event, we ran two equity portfolios through a random Monte Carlo analysis for a 20-year period. For both portfolios, we assumed a $100 initial investment and withdrawals of $5 a year. To isolate the risk drag associated with withdrawals, we also factored in a compound annual return of 8% for both portfolios, though annual volatility was set at 16% for Portfolio A and at 12% (a 25% reduction) for Portfolio B.
As the display below illustrates, both portfolios ended the 20 years with about the same average balance. However, the range of probable outcomes was far narrower for the less volatile portfolio, and its downside potential was dramatically lower. In 90% of scenarios, Portfolio B ended up with a balance of $49 or more, nearly five times higher than that of Portfolio A. As important, the probability of running out of money was one in 67 of the possible scenarios for the lower-risk portfolio, versus one in 14 for the riskier portfolio.
More volatility is not always bad. We could get lucky and end up with more money, as we see in the simplified example above, but we could also end up with less money—or worse, outliving our funds.
In the absence of a crystal ball, we believe that investors in the post-accumulation stages are better off with a plan that will temper the impact of market ups and downs. They will then be more likely to:
- stay the course, in turn allowing them to
- catch opportunities in upswings,
- help preserve more of those gains in downturns and
- significantly reduce the chances of ending up with the worst-case scenario.
Editor’s Note: The author’s views and conclusions in the above article are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original post. Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor.
*http://blog.alliancebernstein.com/index.php/2014/08/07/volatility-in-retirement-what-a-drag/ (© 2014 AllianceBernstein L.P.)
If you liked this article then “Follow the munKNEE” & get each new post via
There are many indicators available that provide information on stock and index movement to help you time the market and make money. Market strength and volatility are two such categories of indicators and a description of six of them are described in this “cut and save” article. Read on! Words: 974 Read More »
I am surprised at the large number of investment professionals who confuse risk and volatility… regularly and thoroughly confusing these two concepts to the point where the terms are treated as being virtually synonymous. This has resulted in the flawed investment principle that reducing volatility will (and must) reduce risk. Such thinking is deeply misguided, and following it has dire consequences for investors. [Let me explain more about what risk and volatility are and are not.] Words: 1100 Read More »
On a theoretical basis, everyone knows to buy when others are fearful, to be contrarian, to avoid panic. On a practical basis, [however,] hardly anyone has the discipline and courage to act. [Below I outline] three ways that the individual investor can profit from the current volatility. Words: 614 Read More »
A big financial challenge retirees face is ensuring their savings last the rest of their lives. It’s a daunting task for those making the transition into retirement as well as for those already in retirement. While saving as much as possible during your working years is important, the decisions you make in retirement are also very important. Fortunately, there are steps you can take to improve your odds of financial success. Here are 10 of them. Read More »
Withdrawing from a $1,000,000 nest egg upon retirement using the familiar 4% rule to generate a successful 30-year inflation-adjusted (3% per annum) retirement proved to be totally inadequate as per the retirement withdrawal strategy that I put forth in a previous article (1). In fact, it crashed and burned in year 25 of the 30-year plan! In fact, as I show in this article, it will only succeed if your portfolio outperforms the S&P 500 by 5% every year for 30 straight years – and what is the likelihood of that? Words: 1533 Read More »
Determine whether you have the time, discipline, and emotional make-up to handle your own finances. Most people think they can succeed on their own, much like the vast majority of people think they are above average drivers. The data shows a different fact pattern. An 18 year study compiled by legendary Vanguard Group founder, John Bogle has shown that the average investor gets destroyed not only by fees, taxes and transactions costs, but also more importantly due to emotional errors and lack of investing discipline. Words: 847 Read More »
Retirement planning is more intimidating for most than any other personal finance topic. We know we should be saving but not how much. We know it’s important to use a tax-deferred account but not which one. Most devastatingly, we often leave saving itself completely up to chance trusting that we will have enough willpower to set money aside for 30-50 years. Luckily, finding a secure and enjoyable retirement need not be mysterious. Here’s exactly what to do. Read More »
Just 10 years ago, most Americans felt confident they’d hang up their hat by the time they turned 60. Now the average working stiff expects to retire at age 65 due to the housing crisis and credit crunch, among other nest egg busters….Experts are predicting that the trend will continue, thanks to the Great Recession so, for now, Americans are just focused on keeping their day jobs. When will you retire? Check out the graphic below to find out. Read More »
Americans spend more time planning their vacations than their retirement and this is the reason why 1 out 7 baby boomers are going bankrupt. With people living longer and spending as much as 30 years in retirement, if you want to maintain a moderate standard of living, it is essential to plan your retirement well in advance to secure your golden years. This article outlines 6 ways to do just that. Words: 665 Read More »
Constructing a portfolio for the retirement years requires one to focus on portfolio risk or uncertainty while not neglecting return. If the portfolio asset allocation plan is too conservative, the return will not meet lifestyle expectations. Inflation is again on the rise and this needs to be taken into consideration when putting together a retirement oriented portfolio. Below is a combination of index ETFs that project respectable returns while holding down portfolio volatility. Words: 455 Read More »