The inherent deficiencies in our system virtually guarantee that long-term implications of massive debt will be ignored. Unfortunately, the “long-term” may finally be upon us, and a dollar collapse of shocking proportions is increasingly likely. This Depression is just getting started. Words: 1011
The value of a currency is determined by a number of variables. In this article, I will focus on the dynamics of demand, supply, current account deficits, and aggregate government debt.
Demand for Dollars
The dollar has enjoyed a boost in demand and an exchange rate premium due to its privileged role as the world’s reserve currency. As a function of this status, world trade is, for the most part, transacted in dollars. However, recent developments on the periphery have slowly undermined the dollar’s dominant position in global trade.
World trade in dollars has been declining since the start of the decade. Recent currency swap agreements between countries, mostly involving China, have been used to bypass the dollar in global trade. Arrangements such as these threaten the dollar’s role as the global reserve currency, removing any support to the dollar’s value such an arrangement provided. This decreased demand is clearly reflected by a falling percentage of foreign reserves held in dollars.
Further, in a low interest rate environment, the dollar has become the carry trade currency of choice. Investors have long been waiting for a powerful countertrend rally in the dollar, but as the example in the yen shows, prolonged weakness in carry trade currencies can and do occur. Also keep in mind that alternative assets, such as gold, become much more attractive in an environment where yields are essentially 0%.
It’s been well-documented that the Fed has embarked on a campaign of massive monetary stimulus. Unfortunately, it’s hard to quantify the extent of money supply growth, since the government has stopped reporting M3 money supply figures.
The real problem brewing under the surface are accumulating bank reserves, which can be thought of as a proxy for risk aversion. Once these reserves are deployed, expect inflation to increase significantly. Sooner or later, banks will have to focus on their core business, which is lending to consumers.
Current Account Deficits
Current account deficits are the quantifiable measure of a country’s profligacy and overconsumption. Current account deficits are historically a short-term solution to a nation’s underproductivity, which must eventually be settled through the balancing of capital and current accounts. As a nation continually funds consumption via debt, its currency naturally becomes less and less valuable as a medium of exchange.
Current account deficits as a percent of GDP in the U.S. have exploded to troubling levels, especially since President Nixon removed the last vestiges of our link to gold in 1971. Over the long run, the value of a currency is inversely correlated to the level of current account deficits. Persistent imbalances in current account deficits will weaken a currency without exception. The downward trend over the last decade in the dollar evidences the detrimental effect of long-term current account deficits. Gold, as an alternative to the dollar, has risen in response to rising current account deficits.
U.S. Government Debt and the Treasury Market
Moving forward, the Treasury market will inordinately dictate major moves in the dollar. Before I explain why, I want to briefly overview the relationship between treasury debt, inflation, and the value of the dollar under the Maestro, Alan Greenspan.
The “great moderation” in the Greenspan years was facilitated by the recycling of dollars into our capital accounts such as stocks, treasury debt, and agency debt. This meant that inflation was temporarily stifled as dollars were sterilized in debt instruments, while asset prices received a jolt from the attendant low interest rates. Furthermore, the tremendous demand for U.S. capital products proved to be supportive of the dollar. If there ever were a period of getting “something for nothing” in America, it was during this era of massively inflated asset prices, and moderate consumer price inflation.
Now what happens when our debt grows to a level that forces the government to become a major player in the bond market? Foreign actors will start unloading their treasury debt, especially on the long end of the yield curve, to an increasingly overburdened government. As demand for Treasuries falls, yields will rise, which makes the burdens of servicing debt greater.
The monumental and ever-increasing level of debt the government has directly taken on through its program of quantitative easing is troubling. The reason is simple: in an inflationary environment, the Fed will be inhibited from containing inflation by selling bonds in the open market, and thereby, soaking liquidity from the system. Due to the sheer size of our program of monetization, any move to sell treasury instruments will likely be met with panic from foreign investors. This is something to keep in mind moving forward.
Total Debt Including Unfunded Liabilities
Now we come to the elephant in the room: aggregate government debt, including unfunded liabilities. Decades of kicking the debt-can down the road in Ponzi scheme entitlement programs, like Social Security, has created a behemoth of debt that is quite literally unpayable. Absent a growth miracle, and a bigger miracle of fiscal austerity by our government, there is no way we can fund these accruing liabilities through our dwindling tax base… If recent government actions are any indication, our government will attempt to mask insolvency through the printing press.
A weaker dollar poses tremendous complications for Americans. For one, it makes imports more expensive, which is effectively inflation. Ultimately, this means a standard of living lower than what we have come to expect. If confidence in the dollar totally erodes, then things will really get ugly.
The comments above are edited ([ ]) and abridged (…) excerpts from an article by Moses Kim