Saturday , 30 May 2020


This May Be A Generational Buying Opportunity Of A Lifetime – Here’s Why

Automatically receive the internet’s most informative articles bi-weekly via our free bi-weekly Market Intelligence Report newsletter (sample here). Register in the top right hand corner of this page.

The charts and indicators provided in this post point to an increasingly bullish medium-term outlook for global equities (particularly global ex-US) and, as such, suggests that this may well be a generational buying opportunity.

Chart #1: Market Breadth Meltdown

The chart below shows the proportion of countries we track (70) whose main equity benchmark is positive on a year over year basis. Much like the traditional market breadth indicators that track individual stocks, this indicator helps identify emerging strength and weaknesses, divergences, and turning points for global equities by tracking countries.

After turning up in 2019, the indicator crossed above the 60% mark (a useful point of delineation for minimizing false positives)…but subsequently collapsed activating the first of 3 possible signals.

chart of global equity market breadth indicator

What to watch for:  Aside from the 60% rule, buying opportunities can be found in two other situations:

  1. most risky is when breadth collapses to below 20%,
  2. less risky – but not without false positives – is when market breadth collapses and then turns up (eyeballing the chart you can see several instances of this).

At this point we have the first one [the 60% rule], but of course neither of the other two signals (yet).

Chart #2: Valuation Breadth

…The chart below shows the proportion of countries we track (in this case a narrower universe of 47 countries – basically all the countries in the MSCI EM + DM indexes) whose PE10 (price vs 10 year average trailing earnings) is either below 15x (a best guess for what represents a “cheap” valuation) and 25x on the top side (a best guess for what represents an “expensive” valuation).

As you can see, the proportion of countries trading on cheaper valuations moved from a low of 23% earlier this year, to now almost 70%. In other words, in the wake of the market crash, 2/3rds of the world now see their equity market trading on cheap valuations.

valuation breadth chart

What to watch for: 

  • This is about as good as it gets, but of course it did go slightly higher at the deep dark depths of the financial crisis so, as always, “cheap can get cheaper”.
  • The other thing to note is that there are still some markets which, although cheaper now vs a couple of months ago, are still historically high…

Chart #3: PE10 Valuations

This is a remarkable chart…[in that it shows that]:

  1. the Emerging Markets PE10 ratio has dropped all the way back to 2003 levels, surpassing the lows of both 2015/16 and 2008/09…
  2. the Developed Markets (excluding the USA) are rapidly closing in on the 08/09 lows and
  3. the USA, which although a lot cheaper (or should we say less expensive), is not quite reverted back to the lows of 2015/16, and remains materially higher relative to the 2009 low

chart of global PE 10 valuations

What to watch for:

At this point:

  • medium/longer term investors…[should] be mentally salivating, as there are fairly clear and proven links between valuation levels and future expected returns (PE10 valuations have a strong inverse correlation with 10-year forward returns). Again though, the adage that cheap can get cheaper applies, and for shorter-term investors it’s interesting information, but not by itself enough to drive short term trading decisions.
  • those who can ride out the short-term volatility will likely be keenly rebalancing [their portfolios] into equities, if not building substantial exposure especially with respect to emerging and DM ex-US.

Chart #4: Global Monetary Policy Pivot

…One of the final pieces of the puzzle is monetary policy (note: cycle indicators matter too, but tend to turn much later, and in the current environment may well be outright misleading)…Another round of rate cuts has…[occurred and[ typically, the more banks cutting rates the more supportive it is for global equities.

central bank interest rate vs equities graph

What to watch for:

  • The thing to watch for is the steadily shrinking traditional policy ammunition that is available globally (China is probably the last one with any sizable traditional monetary policy ammunition left)…

Chart #5: Global Policy Pivot

…We are witnessing a global monetary and fiscal policy response that is on par with the financial crisis, and by the time all is said and done, could easily far exceed what was implemented back then.

chart of global central banks and equities

What to watch for:

  • The main thing to watch for…is the scale of easing vs the progression of the pandemic. Sooner or later it will reach a tipping point, and markets will begin to price in a rebound in growth that will inevitably come on the other side of the pandemic.
  • In the short-term it…[depends on] the decisiveness and resoluteness of world leaders to do what needs to be done to drive a peak in the pandemic, and failing that to ultimately develop and roll out a vaccine.
  • In the medium-term we are faced with a set of initial signals that point to a favorable medium-term outlook for global equities

Bottom line

We are seeing initial signals in technicals, valuations, and monetary/fiscal policy that make for an increasingly bullish medium-term outlook for global equities (particularly global ex-US). As outlined above, however, the short-term outlook is veiled in uncertainty as to whether it’s a short, sharp crash, and then back to business, or a more drawn out bear market – likely with a couple of false dawns.

In times like these, investors who can lengthen up their time frame will have the advantage. The ones who will also have the advantage are those who can focus-in on time-tested signals and indicators – tied together with an overarching framework/process… and not allow their emotions or the noise/news flow to unduly or unjustifiably rock their conviction.

Good luck out there, and stay safe.

  • It may be a time to take risk with capital, but not with health, so make sure you follow best practice and even take the time and opportunity to make some positive health changes…and remember: we are all in this together, and kindness and connection goes a long way!
Editor’s Note:  The original article by Callum Thomas has been edited ([ ]) and abridged (…) above for the sake of clarity and brevity to ensure a fast and easy.  The author’s views and conclusions are unaltered and no personal comments have been included to maintain the integrity of the original article.  Furthermore, the views, conclusions and any recommendations offered in this article are not to be construed as an endorsement of such by the editor. Also note that this complete paragraph must be included in any re-posting to avoid copyright infringement.

Scroll to very bottom of page & add your comments on this article. We want to share what you have to say!

One comment

  1. William Costello

    Thank you for your insight s during this difficult time