Monday , 21 August 2017


The P/E Ratio: Its Strengths and Limitations

When it comes to valuing stocks, the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is the number one metric for investors that want an instant fix on what the market thinks of a company. [That being said]…there are health warnings to heed if you don’t want to be left exposed by its limitations. [Let me explain.] Words: 1101

The comments above & below are edited ([ ]) and abridged (…) excerpts from the original article written by Ben Hobson (www.stockopedia.co.uk)

What is the P/E ratio?

The price/earnings, P/E, or ‘multiple’ as it is sometimes called, compares:

  • a company’s stock price with its historic earnings per share (EPS)… It is effectively a shorthand for how expensive or cheap a share is compared with its profits. Alternatively, it can be calculated by dividing the company’s market capitalisation by its total annual earnings….
  • at times you will see the stock price divided by the forecast EPS as a way of producing a ‘predicted’ P/E ratio using analysts’ expectations as a guide [while]
  • other times the EPS figure will be produced from the past two quarters and the forecast two quarters in order to smooth out the lag between annual results – this is known as the ‘rolling’ P/E…

Another complication is that P/E ratios may be based on either reported earnings (i.e. exactly as per the company’s annual report) or normalised earnings (i.e. with adjustments for exceptional or non-recurring items). Normalised earnings, in our opinion, make for much more meaningful comparisons between companies.

What the P/E tells you

The P/E is a measure of how highly valued the company’s earnings are in the market by telling you:

  1. what an investor is prepared to pay for every $1 of those earnings and
  2. how many years an investor would have to wait to get back his investment through current earnings (assuming all earnings are paid out as dividends, which would be somewhat unusual of course!).

In essence, the P/E tells us the degree of confidence that investors have in the future of the business. A low P/E ratio of, say, 3 or 5 would show very little confidence in the sustainability of that business whereas a much higher P/E of 30+ expresses a great deal of optimism about the future of a business.

In the case of value investors, they are very focused on buying stocks that are trading at very low P/Es, believing that this represents a bargain (especially if the P/E is low compared to historic averages).

In the case of growth investors, the P/E is seen as less meaningful since they hope that current earnings will soon multiply. Investors that want to adjust the PE to take account of growth forecasts should refer to the price-earnings growth ratio (PEG)…

Academic research has found that all other things being equal, shares on a low P/E ratio outperform those on a high P/E ratio over the long term (‘the value effect’)…but in the short term, and especially in bull market runs, high P/E ‘glamour’ stocks have the ability to outperform low P/E ‘value’ stocks.

Where the P/E falls down

Despite being a byword for valuation, P/E has its detractors and many of them have a gripe about the use of earnings as an indicator.

1. Unlike other metrics such as cash flow and dividends, earnings can be subject to manipulation at company level, which means P/E can be distorted depending on how the company has accounted for particular itemsThe fact that accounting standards vary from country to country only adds to that problem. [In an effort to overcome such shortcomings,] Warren Buffett instead judges performance using “owner earnings“, which is defined as:

  • net income
  • plus non-cash charges of depreciation and amortization
  • less capital expenditures and any additional working capital that might be needed…

Buffett argues that owner earnings reflect the true cash flow generation of a company.

If using earnings as a single indicator of a company’s profitability is risky then using P/E as an indicator for valuation is perilous without taking other metrics into consideration.

  • A low P/E ratio could reflect market expectations that bad news is on the way – meaning that an apparently attractively priced stock could suddenly become a basket case.
  • A high P/E ratio may indicate that the market has recognised the future earnings potential of a company and has priced it accordingly. If that company slips up, the investor is at risk of seeing the value tumble as market enthusiasm evaporates.

Therefore, without comparing the P/E of a company with, say, its history, its sector or the market as a whole, the ratio can be misinterpreted or rendered utterly meaningless. As a result, investors will often use it to measure a company against its peers and use the P/E of an overall sector as a benchmark.

2. The use of P/E…is particularly troublesome for investors in small cap stocks, and particularly those companies involved in natural resources. For stocks with little or no earnings history (yet possibly boasting substantial asset bases and/or other upside potential), the P/E is likely to be non-existent or otherwise useless. As a result, in the case of junior oil & gas and mining companies, P/E is usually ditched as a measure of value in favour of metrics such as net asset value, independent reports and the management’s track record.

3. A final weakness is that, by focusing on price/market capitalisation, the P/E ignores the impact of debt and, for that reason, it is arguably inferior to measures like Entreprise Value (EV) to EBITDA or EV/Free Cash Flow. These measures are widely used by professional investors as – unlike the P/E – they are neutral to the capital structure of the company in question (i.e. they are not distorted by leverage).

The value of P/E

P/E offers investors a straightforward formula for valuing a stock and, as a result, it is frequently found in the stock-buying strategies of some of the world’s most successful investors. Critics have bemoaned its inability to take account of growth and the fact that, on its own, the P/E has limited meaning.

Conclusion

However, if investors take account of the known risks, the ratio offers an important valuation and benchmarking tool.

Scroll to very bottom of page & add your comments on this article. We want to share what you have to say!

Thanks for reading! If you want more articles like the one above visit our Facebook page (here) and “Like” any article so you can get future articles automatically delivered to your feed. You can also “Follow the munKNEE” on Twitter or register to receive our FREE tri-weekly newsletter (see sample here , sign up in top right hand corner).

Remember: munKNEE should be in everybody’s inbox and MONEY in everybody’s wallet!

Related Articles from the munKNEE Vault:

1. Don’t Invest in Mutual Funds! Here’s Why

The amount of evidence stacking up that…mutual funds…do not provide value for their investors is just staggering…While there are certainly signs that the public’s tolerance of excessive fees and executive pay is falling, the likelihood of significant structural change in the finance industry is still remote. Given such a backdrop the probability remains that investors in funds will, on average, continue to underperform their benchmarks. So what is an investor to do? [Read on!] Words: 830

2. Should Technical Analysis Be Ignored? We Think So – Here’s Why

The Web is crawling with technical analysis (TA)…[and,] given its popularity, [begs the questions as to whether or not there] really is something to it. [Based on our research,] the short answer is no, not really, at least not in developed markets like the US or the UK… Furthermore, most of the popular TA indicators that are bandied around are nonsense jargon and should be ignored as useless noise. [Let us explain our position.] Words: 2143

3. Motivated Stock Pickers CAN Beat the Market! Here’s How

What hope can there be for motivated stock pickers – no matter how much they sweat and toil – to outperform the low-cost index funds that simply mechanically track the market? Well – in spite of the absurd rise of the Nobel-acclaimed, and highly promoted, Efficient Market Hypothesis that claims that individual investors can’t beat the market – it turns out there is plenty! Just ask Warren Buffett, for one. [Let me explain.] Words: 1574

4. Extreme Investing: Do Leveraged ETFs Belong in Your Portfolio?

Some analysts and commentators are warning that this year (2012) could match or surpass the dire conditions experienced in 2008 with the promise of more turbulence from the Eurozone, further political wrangles over dealing with the U.S. budget deficit and a potential host of problems in emerging market countries such as a possible Chinese banking and real estate crash. [While you] should fear plummeting stock markets…there are actually some interesting ways to play the downside or hedge your portfolio. [Let me explain.] Words: 990

5. I’m Hooked on Dividends – Here’s Why

Dividends aren’t just for Warren Buffett and retirees. Dividends have the power to support your goals of becoming independently wealthy. Here are 3 reasons why. Words: 586

6. Your Portfolio Isn’t Adequately Diversified Without 7-15% in Precious Metals – Here’s Why

The traditional view of portfolio management is that three asset classes, stocks, bonds and cash, are sufficient to achieve diversification. This view is, quite simply, wrong because over the past 10 years gold, silver and platinum have singularly outperformed virtually all major widely accepted investment indexes. Precious metals should be considered an independent asset class and an allocation to precious metals, as the most uncorrelated asset group, is essential for proper portfolio diversification. [Let me explain.] Words: 2137

7. Size Does Matter: A Look at Market Capitalization and What It Means for Investors

People choose certain stocks for many different reasons – business location; sector strength; product innovation – but some investors choose what to buy based on company size, or market capitalization [believing that size does matter. Yes, understanding the difference between small-cap, medium-cap and large-cap companies is the first step to making the right choice. [Let me explain.] Words: 600

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *